COTE v16 chapter 3 part 2.3

The only sad thing is Kyoto, which is not talked about at all. It just increased my taste ...

Then, Horikita's vote, which first chose Kyoto as option 2, may not have moved. Of course, Horikita is Hokkaido or Okinawa

It's not even certain because there's a possibility that someone else might have voted for and put it in Kyoto. I’d like to get even one with the most votes.

There is also a powerful move, but it is easy to leave a grudge. Okinawa won the first vote, regardless of Hokkaido's binary.

"It can't be helped. If this happens, I think there is no choice but to decide by the game. Three people who want Hokkaido, Okinawa is rare.

3 people who want it. Choose a representative for each and have them play rock-paper-scissors. A leader with another two member.

It's a game. However For Kyoto, which has a small number of votes, I will leave it alone. It ’s a tough battle, but to maintain fairness as much as possible. ”

Kyoto, which is a minority, can compete with the other two on an equal footing because it certainly makes us feel unfair.

Should we use this method if we want to put together without force and time?

It is unavoidable that some dissatisfaction remains, but if you decide the rules first, you have to obey.

Participants will soon begin to be decided, although some will be picked up depending on who will be the representative of rock-paper-scissors.

Hokkaido Team Leader, 

Maezono, Nakadanaka, Ishikura

Okinawa team

 Onodera Nakado, Shinohara,

 Sudou

OR

"The other person who voted for Kyoto, could anyone join the rock-paper-scissors?"

Horikita wants one representative. One man raises his hand with full satisfaction.

"If no one comes out, I will put it out as a general. The work will definitely take people to Kyoto."

It was enlightenment that expressed such a strong will and put himself into a tough battle.

A Kyoto school student who raised his voice for the first time. Kyoto is also my desired school trip destination.

I'll leave it to you. It will be a tough battle, but please manage to win ...

In order to make it in time for the third vote, when rock-paper-scissors can be started quickly, first of all, Maezono against the sudou issued by Onodera

Sudou opposes at the par. The Okinawa team will easily win first. The Kyoto team, The Kyoto team, whose dream was broken in an instant, was disappointed and finished.

It was less than 10 seconds after he announced battle result.

I witnessed the moment when Horikita put her hand on forehead and sighed, and I was convinced that she was the one who always wanted to go to Kyoto.

The game continues as if there was no such Kyoto hope group from the beginning. Onodera, who defeated two people in the first match, is a good player.

Win two consecutive victories to break the stone and make a check at once. However, Shinohara who appeared as a leader defeats Onodera in quick succession.

It was an unexpected development.

Then, they get involved in the battle between the leader, and both appear.

"Absolutely Okinawa!  Beach ! Snorkel!"

"Absolutely Hokkaido! Hot springs! Skiing!"

Clench your fists, saying things you don't understand.

When both of them swing up and swing down, each other's hands are bars. 

I'd like to go to Kyoto soon, but both sides stop moving and take a break.

I'm just deciding where to go on my school trip, but it's an extraordinary tension.

"Ready ! Rock-paper-scissors!"

We had a second collision. What Sudou served was a powerful rock. 

 the other Shinohara threw a brilliant paper for two consecutive times.

"I did it !! It's Hokkaido !!"

Wow, the Hokkaido faction wins all at once.

"What are you doing, Sudou!"

I don't want to throw cold water on you, but Hokkaido is the only place in this class. With this, Okinawa or Kyoto.

If I get two votes more vote , I'll can go there. 

I wonder if Horikita understands that it is not the kind of atmosphere to say that. 

This is the third vote, and everyone operates the tablet all at once.

3rd Voting Results: Hokkaido 39, Kyoto 0, Okinawa 0

"The second challenge is clear because the third vote was unanimous"

Although about half of the dissatisfaction remains, the place is perfectly matched in the third vote due to a fair battle according to the set rules.

Succeed in achieving I couldn't realize what I wanted in Kyoto, but I'm really looking forward to Hokkaido and depending on the trends of other classes, Kyoto and offshore.

There is plenty of rope left.

Anyway, no matter where I was, I couldn't wait for my school trip.

"Then let me move on to the third task."

The appearance was the same from the beginning, but there was a slight change in the tone of his voice.

There may be a change in the flow from the easy tasks so far.

Task 3 - Instead of giving zero points to three random students in the class every month, they will be given protective points. 

Or 

the private points to be paid will be halved to any one person. 

If neither of them is desired, then  private points can given to bottom five students in the next written examination  

※No matter which option is selected, the confiscation period of private points lasts for half a year.

The two tasks up to this point were the ones that included major advantages and disadvantages in the class.

Option 1 has a greater payback in terms of private points lost, but the fact that it is given to a random student cannot be overlooked.

Protected points are a very powerful system, but depending on your perspective, some students may end up not needing them for three years.

There are some students who end up not needing them for three years. If they are given to such students, it could be a waste of points.

Option 2 is also not inexpensive, as it cuts the amount of Private Points that can be transferred in half.

 Moreover, only one person will be granted

only one student. However, being able to choose any student is an important factor.

Option 3 is to minimize the loss of Private Points as much as possible. If you decide that the protection points are too expensive.

Or,

 if you don't need it in the first place, this is the option you will choose.

However, it is important to remember that even with five players, you still have a disadvantage.

You should not forget that you will have disadvantages even with five players.

In addition to calculating the profit and loss, it is also necessary to consider the class situation.

Some students may have a lot to say, but there is no other way but to vote.

Before we vote, let's talk about the case when the vote is unanimous for option 2, the option to give to a particular student.

If option 2 is unanimous, task 3 will not be cleared and the next option will continue to determine one person.

You remember the example, don't you ?

The interval will be used to select one student and collect votes for or against granting the student. 

If the vote is unanimous in favor, the student will receive a protection point, and if the vote is unanimous against, the student's chances in the assignment will be zero.

Then again remaining students discuss the issue and choose one person.

"Based on this, we will announce the result of the first vote."

1st voting result : Random three students ( 12) ,one student choosen ( 5 ) , without Granting ( 22)

TLNote :  I can’t grasp the meaning properly of 3rd options as [付与なし22票].

The results of the first round of voting seemed to indicate that the majority of people were willing to give up their protection points for a few inconveniences.

This is true. The five people who would lose their private points were already determined to be the bottom five in the written exam.

For those who don't apply, it's a good part to have no risk. On the other hand, private points are for half a year anyway

If you know you won't be able to get in, you might think it's better to get a protect point.

"Wait a minute! I'm not convinced!"

"Me too !  Me too ! Without protect points, only 5 people would lose!"

Ike and Sato were the first to speak out. These are the students who seem to have lower grades.

"Well, it can't be helped. It's a bit ...... difficult to get private points for six months ... and use”

“The probability of ike is low, and I don't think I can convince them if they are specific.

I tell you to remember. I'm already out of the bottom five in my academic ability ” (Sudou)

"It's unfair! I need a lot of private points right now!" (ike)

"You're not going to tell me you're paying for a date with Shinohara, are you?"

"Huh? What? Seriously, how did you find out? Oh my god... ..."

It seems that it is a matter of life and death, although it seems that it does not come to the point that the usage is out of order